Russians Say Iran Closer To Nuclear Bomb

[John317]

Denis Dyomkin – Mon Jul 12, 11:14 am ET

MOSCOW (Reuters) – Russian President Dmitry Medvedev said Monday Iran was gaining the ability to build a nuclear bomb, remarks welcomed in Washington as a sign of growing international unity behind a tough line toward Tehran.

Medvedev's comments were the strongest criticism of Iran's nuclear program to emerge from the Kremlin under either Medvedev or his predecessor, Prime Minister Vladimir Putin.

A major goal of U.S. President Barack Obama's "reset" of relations with Moscow has been winning Russian backing for a tougher international line toward Iran.

"It is obvious that Iran is moving closer to possessing the potential which in principle could be used for the creation of nuclear weapons," Medvedev told a meeting of Russia's ambassadors in Moscow.

"Iran is not acting in the best way," Medvedev said. He called on Tehran to "show openness and cooperate" with the U.N. nuclear watchdog, the International Atomic Energy Agency.

The United States, major European Union powers and Israel say they suspect that Iran is trying to build atomic weapons under the cover of its civilian nuclear program. Iran denies this and says it has a right to nuclear power.

"GOOD SIGN," SAYS U.S.

"This is about as blunt as Medvedev has ever been about Iran's nuclear program and should be taken as a good sign of increased international unity on Iran's nuclear program," an Obama administration official said in Washington.

Urged on by the Obama administration, Russia voted for a U.N. Security Council resolution on June 9 to impose new sanctions on Iran over its nuclear program. Medvedev said he was still skeptical of sanctions but they could prod diplomacy.

"I have said before that sanctions as a rule do not have the desired results. Their role is to send a signal, to stimulate the negotiating process," Medvedev said.

Moscow has been Tehran's main nuclear partner, building Iran's first nuclear power plant near the city of Bushehr, which is set to begin operations later this year. Russia was also swift to congratulate Iran's President Mahmoud Ahmadinejad on a disputed election victory last year.

But Russia has been dismayed by Iran's failure to disclose full details of its nuclear work and Medvedev has expressed growing concern in recent months about Tehran's nuclear aims.

Kremlin officials were furious when the Iranian leader admonished Medvedev in May for bowing to what Ahmadinejad said was U.S. pressure to agree sanctions.

The Kremlin chief, who diplomats say still defers to Putin on major policy issues such as Iran, said last month he was alarmed by U.S. assertions that Iran had enough fuel for a nuclear weapon.

Resolution of the Iranian nuclear issue would involve a great deal of patience and energy, but the consequences of failure to deal with it would be grave, Medvedev said.

"At the moment, patience is demanded and the speediest resumption of productive dialogue with Tehran," Medvedev said. "If diplomats let this chance go, then this will become a collective failure for the entire international community."

(Additional reporting by Patricia Zengerle in Washington; Writing by Guy Faulconbridge and Peter Graff; editing by David Stamp)

[John317]

Bravus, I'd be interested in your opinion about this. Do you still think Iran isn't interested in obtainting the nuclear bomb?

[phkrause]

You know what's funny about this, is the fact that all these countries keep saying this but don't do anything about it. All they do is flap there jaws.

[Bravus]

Medvedev is a political leader, not a scientist or inspector. The IAEA says:

http://www.iaea.org/NewsCenter/Focus/IaeaIran/index.shtml

(well, lots really - but it boils down to 'Iran is cooperating with international inspections')

There are plenty of good political reasons why international political leaders including Medvedev and Obama might want to be seen as being 'tough on Iran' around the issue, and Ahmadinejad's crazy nonsense certainly doesn't help, but on the balance of the evidence, I still believe Iran is seeking nuclear technology purely for energy generation purposes.

[Bravus]

In fairness, sections 34 to the end of the document in this document do show that the IAEA has some concerns, which it's continuing to work through with Iran.

http://www.iaea.org/Publications/Documents/Board/2010/gov2010-28.pdf

The overall report, however, shows that the actual facilities are producing fuel for nuclear reactors, not nuclear weapons.