hobie Posted September 5 Posted September 5 Adventist know what Jude says about Enoch and we see him in the lineage. Genesis 4:18 And unto Enoch was born Irad: and Irad begat Mehujael: and Mehujael begat Methusael: and Methusael begat Lamech. Luke 3:37 Which was the son of Mathusala, which was the son of Enoch, which was the son of Jared, which was the son of Maleleel, which was the son of Cainan, However, the Book of Enoch itself is not recognized as the inspired Word of God or a part of the Biblical Canon and there is a good reason. It seems that parts of it were added later or corrupted by other writers as its shifts in tone that don't fit the style and narrative of the book and the other parts of Enoch could have been authored by others so does not meet the standards for Canon. The book diverges from a biblical view, and the early church did not consider it consistent with the other books of the Biblical Canon. The book that is held to be and is even found to exist now was not written during the lifetime of Enoch, and it shows not one but many authors from the style and uneven content, and it got widespread attention in the Jewish circles because of people thinking it was from the real Enoch. And if you notice it dwells on a area that only demons or fallen angels are concerned and mixes in just a hint of the spiritual themes to give it a cover of a religious or inspired book. But its not... Thus, the fact that the book was written only a couple hundred years before Jesus was born makes it extremely unlikely that anything in it could be from the real Enoch. Now Christ clearly spoke about those of that time, we see it on Noah. Matthew 24:37-39 37 But as the days of Noah were, so shall also the coming of the Son of man be.38 For as in the days that were before the flood they were eating and drinking, marrying and giving in marriage, until the day that Noe entered into the ark,39 And knew not until the flood came, and took them all away; so shall also the coming of the Son of man be. And it came to the point at the time of Noah that God was sorry that He made man because their thoughts were now evil continually. Now the fact is that the Pre-incarnate Christ was been seen by men. Enoch and Noah both "walked with God" so they were both intimately known by Him. Genesis 5:22 And Enoch walked with God after he begat Methuselah three hundred years, and begat sons and daughters: Genesis 6:9 These are the generations of Noah: Noah was a just man and perfect in his generations, and Noah walked with God. Yet nothing on Enoch, Jesus never quotes the Book of Enoch as canonical scripture using introductory formulas like "it is written", and it was circulated widely during this period, but not before. Notice it says that Enoch prophesized so they knew what Enoch had given about Christ. Jude 1:14 And Enoch also, the seventh from Adam, prophesied of these, saying, Behold, the Lord cometh with ten thousands of his saints, From my look into it, the book that was circulating tried to lay claim that it picked up the original writings of Enoch which appear to be the Epistle of Enoch, but then mixed in doctrines of demons and evil angels in the Book 1 The Watchers Book 2 Parables Book 3 Astronomy Book 4 Dreams to confuse what the original Enoch said. Thus Christ kept silent as He knew the truth of the matter. Quote
Gustave Posted November 7 Posted November 7 The 1st 17 minutes of the following video explains why the Book of Enoch is not "currently" in our Bibles. Quote
Gustave Posted November 7 Posted November 7 Hobie, Jesus never quoted Ezra, Nehemiah, Esther, the Song of Solomon, AND Ecclesiastes. Using your rubric those Books should not be in your Bible. The Bible doesn't mention beasts breeding human females and producing confused fruit and a host of other things Ellen White claimed yet you accept those. Why? Quote
Asia Joe Posted November 14 Posted November 14 On 11/7/2026 at 10:22 PM, Gustave said: The Bible doesn't mention beasts breeding human females and producing confused fruit and a host of other things Ellen White claimed Where is that? I would like to study that !!! Quote
Asia Joe Posted November 14 Posted November 14 On 9/6/2026 at 5:50 AM, hobie said: It seems that parts of it were added later or corrupted by other writers as its shifts in tone that don't fit the style and narrative of the book and the other parts of Enoch could have been authored by others so does not meet the standards for Canon. This is why I never accepted it. It is clearly different from the rest. phkrause 1 Quote
Gustave Posted November 14 Posted November 14 13 hours ago, Asia Joe said: Where is that? I would like to study that !!! Surley you jest! But if you are serious pm me your email address and I'll send you what Ellen White said as well as her supporters who defended her (Ellen White) against the Pastors of other denominations who took issue with Ellen claiming beasts bred negresses and produced confused fruit. We might even explore this in a new thread. Quote
Moderators Gregory Matthews Posted Thursday at 01:56 PM Moderators Posted Thursday at 01:56 PM To beglin your stludy of thils ilssue. see: https://m.egwwritings.org/en/book/752.8?hl="Every+species+of+animal+which+God+had+created+were+preserved"&ss=eyJ0b3RhbCI6OCwicGFyYW1zIjp7InF1ZXJ5IjoiXCJFdmVyeSBzcGVjaWVzIG9mIGFuaW1hbCB3aGljaCBHb2QgaGFkIGNyZWF0ZWQgd2VyZSBwcmVzZXJ2ZWRcIiIsInR5cGUiOiJiYXNpYyIsImxhbmciOiJlbiIsImxpbWl0IjoiMjAifSwiaW5kZXgiOjV9 Quote Gregory
Moderators Gregory Matthews Posted Thursday at 03:03 PM Moderators Posted Thursday at 03:03 PM In a study of this issue it is important to consider the following: * The phrase "almagation of man and beast" has a different mealning than tlhe phrase "almagation of maln with beast.' I consider it uncertain as ro what EGW acltually thought on thils subject. * Ellen White was a human who was imperfect and not without error. At some stages of her life she was wrong in her ulnderstangings. That does not botherr me. 'the 'Bible is the final standard by which all teachings should be judged, not a falable human being. phkrause 1 Quote Gregory
Gustave Posted Thursday at 03:19 PM Posted Thursday at 03:19 PM At the time these things were claimed by Ellen White there was, outside the SDA Church, some hard pushback by Clergy of other Denominations that took issue with what Ellen White had said. What followed was a vigorous defense of what Ellen White had said in the Sabbath Herald SDA Church Paper. There was zero doubt that Ellen White believed and taught that within certain races of men actual "beasts" (animals) had mated with human females who in turn bore fruit that was confused (i.e. hybrids of Orangutans (and other beasts) and human females. The apologists in the Sabbath Herald appealed to published books and articles of "Naturalists" (sort of a pre-science popular literature). Back when I was researching this subject, I wanted to know what it was that the "Naturalists" were saying so I bought an excellent book called "Images of Savages". In the book the author quotes all the Naturalists that affirmed that in Africa some of the tribes were resultant from Negresses either willingly sexually submitting to Great Apes or actually abducted by great simian brutes where they would be taken into ape strongholds for breeding purposes. To be fair Ellen was not the only person in the nineteenth century to believe this, it was accepted as a fact by the masses of uneducated people who would pay coin to view such amalgamations when the circus came to town. Quote
Moderators Gregory Matthews Posted Thursday at 11:29 PM Moderators Posted Thursday at 11:29 PM To be clear: * It is a reasonable conclusion to say that EGW believed such, based upon her comment.. *l also consider it reasonable to say that EGW hlaas been misunderstood and that it can notbe proven that she did not believe such. * I consider EGW to be an imperfect human being who was used by l/god in the development of the SDA Church. * I should be noted that you do not have to believe that EGW was used by lGod in such a manner in order to be a member of the lSDA Church. Such is not a requirement. phkrause 1 Quote Gregory
Moderators Gregory Matthews Posted yesterday at 01:18 AM Moderators Posted yesterday at 01:18 AM In generall, wlhen i want to understand tlhe beliefs and teachilngs of a public filgure, I look for a body of data that provides me with such information. I do not judge a plublic filgure on the basis okf one isolated statement. This is true for an elelcted officiall, the Pope, okther religious leadrs and my friends. Gustave is corect that EGWs statementl could be understood as he proposes. But, to suggest that such is actulaly her teaching (thinking) on this subject, requiresl muchll more than one isolated statement lthat is not totally clear as to how to understand it. phkrause 1 Quote Gregory
Asia Joe Posted 33 minutes ago Posted 33 minutes ago Quote These are Mrs. White’s only statements on the subject of the amalgamation of man and beast. Just what Mrs. White meant by these passages has been the occasion of some speculation through the years, and two explanations have been set forth. Some have held that she taught not only that men and beasts have cohabited but also that progeny resulted. However, those who hold this view have contended that this does not support the doctrine of evolution. The evolution theory depends for its life on the idea that small, simple living structures can gradually evolve into ever higher forms of life, finally bringing forth man. That more or less closely related forms of life may cross and produce hybrids is not questioned by creationists today. That, in the long ago, when virility was greater, and conditions possibly in some respects different, more diverse forms of life might have crossed—such as man and some higher forms of animals—can be set forth only as an assumption. But this assumption has marshaled against it the whole weight of scientific belief today. Of course, scientists have been wrong, at times, in reasoning that all the past must be understood in terms of the processes we now see going on. https://m.egwwritings.org/en/book/752.8#8 Well I have a different opinion. I live in an area with many different types and colors of lizards. They are very common. When I see the traditional dinosaur picture, I think that is an amalgamation of a Lizard and a Giraffe. The head and tail closely resemble a Lizard and the body resembles a Giraffe. Mrs White says they were very smart before the flood. I read where she said something to the effect, if we took some of our best scalars and put them next to the antediluvian people, there would be no comparison. So if we have genetic engineering today, I am sure they had it back then. There are also excavated remains of humanoid that have large elongated skulls. https://curiosmos.com/here-are-5-of-the-most-bizarre-elongated-skulls-ever-found/ So I suspect they were using genetic engineering on humans too. Why not? According to her and the brief statement in the bible, they we very evil. Now some have postulated that she meant humans and animals mated. I think that is unlikely, however, mixing human and animal genes might have been possible. This is why I am personalty against all forms of genetic changes, including, but not limited to MRNA. I believe our DNA is God given. Jeremiah chapter 1. Quote
Recommended Posts
Join the conversation
You can post now and register later. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.