Help Me Decide

[Sulla]

Hi every one I was wondering if you can help me pick the payout for the Christian TV project I am working on. I have made 4 mockups. They are labeled S1, S2, S3, S4. And S1 would be the cheapest to have done. Please take a look at them at http://www.pwlawrence.com/temp_art/tv/ Then you can tell me what version you like and vote in the poll if I can make it work. And thanks very very much:)

Also each image is labeled on the top right in green.

S1

S2

S3

S4

[Sulla]

Ok from the feed back here and other places it looks like S1 is the clear winner. So I did some other versions of S1. See what you think of them. And sorry no poll for this one as I did not think I should make another thread. Or should I stick with the original S1?

S1C

S1D

1SE I think this is the one I like the best.

[fccool]

I do work in interactive media design, and I think that the S4 Silverlight WebTV look is the best and more intuitive. But it's all up to you.

[Sulla]

I liked S4 also fccool. But the winner of all the feedback I got back from all the different places I asked was S1. Plus S1 was much cheaper to make work correctly so it won:)

Here is the final mockup if your interested. http://www.tvgismo.com/mockup/mockup_test.html

[Neil D]

I bounced back and forth between S2 and S4...Either one looks good to me...But the S1 is too basic...

[Sulla]

Sorry Neil Iliked S4 also but we got out voted:) Also as mentioned S1 costs a lot less to make and since the financing for this project involves stepping out in faith that adds another point in S1s favor.

By the way would any one be interested in me making a little widget that would let you add say 3abn, hope and amazing facts to your website by cutting and pasting?