Jump to content
ClubAdventist

Recommended Posts

Posted

I didn't realize that women ordination was even an issue in the adventist church. What specific problem or danger does a women conference president bring? Is there something she cannot do that a male could? Or would do that a male wouldn't ?

Scott

  • Replies 55
  • Created
  • Last Reply

Top Posters In This Topic

  • ClubV12

    14

  • scott.t

    6

  • olger

    4

  • phkrause

    3

Top Posters In This Topic

Posted

Her ovaries might be injured from on the job stress.... :)

Seriously, the Adventist Church is a bible based doctrine Church. Therefore, doctrine needs to be defined from the "book". Well, the book is not as clear as one might assume by reading this or that passage. The general consensus has been and remains you can make a case for women in a leadership over men, or not. Could go either way, from a biblical stand point.

Obviously everybody uses some verse to support their position. And for every verse that supports, theres another one that doesn't!

Doctrine of the Church is NOT based on current public popular trends. It is NOT based on majority or minority rule. Doctrine is based on what the Church see's as truth of an issue in the bible and has ALWAYS been flexible as it regards "new light". The best definition I've seen of "new light" is that it is "old light" with a new, brighter, deeper understanding. Another facet of the gems of truth.

While I leave room for entirely "new light", new discoveries of truth. Which when correctly understood won't replace any standing doctrine, it will BUILD on old doctrine and there will be a continual golden chain of truth from beginning to end.

Posted

The overwhelming weight of Bible evidence favors male leadership. That's why WO proponents argue from culture.

"Please don't feed the drama queens.."

Posted

Thank you Club and Olger. I understand that some bible verses talk about men being the head of the household and such. And most everyone realizes the culture that the bible was written in, women were considered subservient to men. So I get why a lot of people might be against women ordination, but what specific danger is cited. What will a woman do that is offensive to adventism? What reason does the bible give for not wanting women leaders?

Thanks :)

Scott

Posted

I don't see "culture" as it concerns the biblical counsel with men predominately, but not in every case, being in the leadership roll. Adam was in leadership over Eve BEFORE sin. She was warned to stay close to him, her protector. We see men in leadership rolls all through the bible. The New Testament leaders followed that biblical advice, as should we. Regardless of "culture".

The trick is recognizing the great value of women in ministry, and we see that principle in both Old and New testaments. Equal, but separate rolls.

What is the danger? Complex question, but I will go with the counsel of the bible and rest assured that God has a very good reason for setting things up the way He did. There are many things I don't understand about why God does this or that. Who can know the mind of God?

  • Moderators
Posted

The overwhelming weight of Bible evidence favors male leadership. That's why WO proponents argue from culture.

I must not be a WO proponent then, because my statement is biblical, that we are all one: "There is neither Jew nor Greek, there is neither bond nor free, there is neither male nor female: for ye are all one in Christ Jesus." Gal. 3:28.

This is an issue that should not be divisive. We should not get side-tracked into arguing one side or the other, but all work as part of the body, together forward in the kingdom.

LD

Posted

Originally Posted By: olger
The overwhelming weight of Bible evidence favors male leadership. That's why WO proponents argue from culture.

I must not be a WO proponent then, because my statement is biblical, that we are all one: "There is neither Jew nor Greek, there is neither bond nor free, there is neither male nor female: for ye are all one in Christ Jesus." Gal. 3:28.

This is an issue that should not be divisive. We should not get side-tracked into arguing one side or the other, but all work as part of the body, together forward in the kingdom.

We are all part of the body but we can't all be the head. We need other body parts, too.

Remember Adventists Online?

Posted

Hmmm..and maybe the desire should not be to remain first. Maybe the last is now to become first, so to speak. No, women do not desire to remain first, just to be able to carry out God's desire for them or anyone else. I do see men wanting to remain in charge however.

  • Moderators
Posted

I don't see any mad rush for too many to become the head, but maybe I am too far out in the hinterlands to observe that point. Those who are capable can be recognized as capable, and be given responsibilities where they can excel, whether male or female. Seems like at easy concept to me.

LD

Posted

Sorry Lyndel. My statement was supposed to say "often argue from culture.."

Some make an attempt to use Scripture.

We're even, with one typo apiece "Seems like at easy concept to me."

:)

"Please don't feed the drama queens.."

  • Moderators
Posted

:) Mine's a typo and self-editing blindness; yours is an omission and self-editing blindness. :) One is human frailty and one is a sin. (Kidding)

LD

Posted

I don't see "culture" as it concerns the biblical counsel with men predominately, but not in every case, being in the leadership roll. Adam was in leadership over Eve BEFORE sin. She was warned to stay close to him, her protector. We see men in leadership rolls all through the bible. The New Testament leaders followed that biblical advice, as should we. Regardless of "culture".

The trick is recognizing the great value of women in ministry, and we see that principle in both Old and New testaments. Equal, but separate rolls.

What is the danger? Complex question, but I will go with the counsel of the bible and rest assured that God has a very good reason for setting things up the way He did. There are many things I don't understand about why God does this or that. Who can know the mind of God?

Great answer

Posted

The North American Division of the Adventist Church recently released their study and "paper" presenting a new hermeneutical approach in contrast to the Historical-grammatical approach for interpretation of scripture.

This approach to interpretation would suggest that New Testament counsel/verses are in fact, "culture" based. That such counsel was applicable to the people of that time and that culture. We, being more enlightened, can therefore dismiss specific counsel as relevant to us today if our culture is different than a previous culture.

I believe there is a direct connection between this new type of biblical interpretation and those who support the W.O. movement. It makes certain other wise problematic bible verses fit nicely into support of W.O.

This new method of scripture interpretation represents the opinion of NAD. It is not Church policy or widely accepted by the world Church. I note the recent opinion of NAD as well, their open defiance of the highest levels of leadership in their vote to allow womens ordination.

NAD, picking up speed as they continue down their slippery slope.

  • Moderators
Posted

ClubV12, Here I think you have a point. From what I learned in Jim Fleming's "The Role of Women in the Bible" available through www.biblicalresources.net/jim-fleming-lectures.cfmý Fleming points out that these texts are NOT cultural, but specific applications to specific events, with Paul having a consistent principle. What Fleming argues is that we are reading into the text things that are not there, taking the texts out of their context, ignoring what Paul's practice was in Acts and Romans and make a misinterpretation. Both the opponents of ordination and those who want to excuse the texts as being the "culture" are both taking the texts out of context and misinterpreting them.

  • Moderators
Posted

ClubV12, I wish that you would look at the Fleming material. Those who argue that those verses were "cultural" do not convince me. Fleming's arguments that we are taking those text out of context does convince me.

Posted

The NAD are using the EGW concept of Bible interpretstion as endorced by a GC approval.

Posted

Thanks for the tip Kevin, I'll look into Flemings work.

My opinions on NAD's recent recommendations toward interpretation are still taking shape. My immediate reaction is "caution". The debate over how to interpret scripture goes back a long way in our Church and there are many and varied opinion. I wonder, have we been doing it wrong for quite awhile? I wonder is this new method even worse?

Difficult questions...

Posted

johann says,

"The NAD are using the EGW concept of Bible interpretstion as endorced by a GC approval."

That statement could certainly be argued as to what NAD has been using, what they want to use, what Ellen White says about it and what the G.C.'s opinion is. Like W.O., not everbody agrees on the same method.

While I appreciate those who are well educated and can offer many worthy insights, I am also somewhat cautious toward accepting such insights at face value. Face value because of the many letters after their name, their rank or position.

I like Sister Whites counsel on interpretation. Take the bible just as it reads. One doesn't need even a college education to understand the word. In some cases, higher learning may cause more confusion than clairity!

Posted

Adam was in leadership over Eve BEFORE sin. She was warned to stay close to him, her protector. We see men in leadership rolls all through the bible.

Which is just the start of the problem. If there was no sin, there was no danger so what did she need protection from?

Posted

Good question MT, what DID she need protection from?

That is rather obvious knowing the history. There was a tree, there was a serpant, there was an apple. Had they BOTH stayed together, our history might be very different. There WAS danger in the garden, and Eve found it.

Heaven, before sin, was also perfect. One could say there was no apparent danger. Yet, that is where sin orginated with Lucifer. Sin is a mystery, there really is no explanation for it.

Posted

:) Mine's a typo and self-editing blindness; yours is an omission and self-editing blindness. :) One is human frailty and one is a sin. (Kidding)

Pray for me !

:)

"Please don't feed the drama queens.."

Posted

"The angels had cautioned Eve to beware of separating herself from her husband while occupied in their daily labor in the garden; with him she would be in less danger from temptation than if she were alone. But absorbed in her pleasing task, she unconsciously wandered from his side. On perceiving that she was alone, she felt an apprehension of danger, but dismissed her fears, deciding that she had sufficient wisdom and strength to discern evil and to withstand it. Unmindful of the angels’ caution, she soon found herself gazing with mingled curiosity and admiration upon the forbidden tree. The fruit was very beautiful, and she questioned with herself why God had withheld it from them. Now was the tempter’s opportunity."{CTr 21.3}

"Please don't feed the drama queens.."

Posted

johann says,

"The NAD are using the EGW concept of Bible interpretstion as endorced by a GC approval."

That statement could certainly be argued as to what NAD has been using, what they want to use, what Ellen White says about it and what the G.C.'s opinion is. Like W.O., not everbody agrees on the same method.

While I appreciate those who are well educated and can offer many worthy insights, I am also somewhat cautious toward accepting such insights at face value. Face value because of the many letters after their name, their rank or position.

I like Sister Whites counsel on interpretation. Take the bible just as it reads. One doesn't need even a college education to understand the word. In some cases, higher learning may cause more confusion than clairity!

It might not hurt you to read for yourself what more Ellen White says about inspiration. It does not require a college degree to understand that.

Posted

Genesis 3:6 is pretty clear that Adam was with Eve at the time of the eating of the fruit. The "wandering off" tale is not supported by the biblical text.

God never said "Thou shalt not think".

  • Administrators
Posted

Quote:
We are all part of the body but we can't all be the head. We need other body parts, too.

There is only one head to the body of Christ, and that is Christ.

women develop pecking orders among the women, men develop pecking orders among the men, by nature.

and even children on the playground develop pecking orders.

this is not the way of heaven.

leadership is serving, not controlling.

deb

Love awakens love.

Let God be true and every man a liar.

Join the conversation

You can post now and register later. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.

Guest
Reply to this topic...

×   Pasted as rich text.   Paste as plain text instead

  Only 75 emoji are allowed.

×   Your link has been automatically embedded.   Display as a link instead

×   Your previous content has been restored.   Clear editor

×   You cannot paste images directly. Upload or insert images from URL.


If you find some value to this community, please help out with a few dollars per month.



×
×
  • Create New...