Kevin, appreciate your response.
Please correct me if I am wrong in my assumption. Are the four steps you listed in your first paragraph, the hermeneutics of which “Historical” expositors have used in centuries past to produce the interpretation which “ Historicist” promote to this day, or are they rules that you think are appropriate for interpreting apocalyptic prophecy?
I ask the question because I have not been able to find a standard set of hermeneutics used by “Historicists” through the past ages. The following quote taken from our SDA Bible Commentaries, vol 7, pg. 130 seems to support my conclusion.
“IN Conclusion. Obviously, this discussion of the history of prophetic interpretation is brief all to brief to do full justice to the subject. It has not been possible to turn aside to consider those basic principles of interpretation that must serve as the criterion of the worth of the variant views of the Apocalypse that have been held by different expositors through the centuries. Nevertheless, the simple recital of those views, which reveals an ever-enlarging understanding of the meaning of the apocalyptic symbols of the Revelation, can prove of help in the interpretation …”
This statement would be akin to a first grade teacher teaching on the subject of math. Class, when it comes to math, I am not going to bother teaching you the laws that govern math, addition, multiplication, subtraction and division, instead I will just teach you the answers to math problems.
Any individual who desires to understand apocalyptic prophecy must first understand the hermeneutic or lack of any, (a private interpretation) on which that interpretation is built.
In the quote from our commentaries, none is given, and I suspect their were none recognized or proven to be true based on fulfilled prophecy of the past. Instead it is stated a simple recital of those views prove of help in the interpretation of Revelation. But what is those view were never correct to start with. No concrete hermeneutics are given for one to prove, wether they are correct or not.
Am I making sense here?