Jump to content
ClubAdventist

The Stones are Crying Out


Recommended Posts

Posted

Quote:

calgary_guy said:

Quote:

Nicodema said:

Good grief, who is this guy?
icon_smile_sick.gif
Is this still the voice of the majority in SDA-ism? Ei-yei-yei ...
AAdoh.gif


It would be better to just answer my questions/concerns here with a verifiable fact or two. Hope you have a nice day...:)


Kind of hard to do when someone else's definition of "fact" may begin and end with, "that which is in evidence from people who think exactly like myself." Since it is entirely (objectively speaking) debatable whether (a) such ways of thinking constitute "truth"; and (B) such ways of thinking constitute actual fruit of "being brought to Christ", we would first have to formulate the terms upon which such concerns COULD be addressed, let alone what would constitute "verifiable fact or two" in an arena composed entirely not just of subjective experiences themselves, but -- God help us all! -- of subjective perception of said subjective experiences!!!

Perhaps the above reads a bit unclearly, so let me try again. Anything I might hold forth as evidence that X DOES "reach" people whereas "Y" does not, could simply be brushed aside by claiming those reached by "X" were not "really" reached and conversely, those unreached by "Y", being, well, "unreached," are presumably not in any position to constitute a definitive statement upon the efficacy of "Y" to reach them. So the entire argument is moot from the start because I already know how those who think themselves right about everything are wont to answer any evidence that they are, in fact, not. tongue.gif

That's why I posted the question I posted in the manner in which I posted it. Statistics don't lie.

"After such knowledge, what forgiveness?" -- T.S. Eliot
  • Replies 222
  • Created
  • Last Reply

Top Posters In This Topic

  • there buster

    54

  • Nicodema

    41

  • Michelle

    19

Posted

Quote:

Nicodema said:

That's why I posted the question I posted in the manner in which I posted it. Statistics don't lie.


That's OK Nicodema

We all have a right to an opinion here. smile.gif This is what Ed said that I was questioning.

Quote:

We and other evangelicals have spent millions on methods that, according to Mike Ryan, reach only 3%-4% of the population.

We've spent time arguing about issues that the lost are totally uninterested in, and which have only been snares to most within the church.

And here, in the early 21st century, fantasies that were condemned by many, many prominent SDA leaders (LOTR and Chronicles of Narnia) are drawing huge crowds paying for the privilege of seeing these films.


Here are some questions in my mind as I made my above posts:

1) Who is Mike Ryan? Where can we find his and other documentation that would verify the claims being made by these stats? How do we know these claims fairly represent every church/our church? Statistics actually do lie sometimes, depending on who's doing them why they are, and who they are being presented to.

2/ What issues have we spent time arguing about that are such a snare to most in the Church?

3/ OK. Granted. Narnia is drawing huge crowds. But where are these crowds being drawn to? Are they being drawn to the Church? Does anyone really walk out of that movie and think about Jesus when they walk back to the car? How can we/Ed demonstrate his answer to these questions?

Ed makes some pretty aggressive claims here; but there really is no verification; except his say so. It's easy for me to agree with what Ed is saying re problems with the way the Church does Evangeism/witnessing; however, I am trying to take it even a step further by suggesting that Ed's "method" (re Narnia) is actually on the same level as the rest. Unless Ed shows me really clearly otherwise; that's where I'll have to sit.

Using non-traditional methods of reaching people is good; but only to a certain point. A Pastor I talked to earlier tonight said when he was over in Africa; a warparty of natives with clubs approached him because he had a camera. The biggest guy said to the Pastor: "YOU TAKE MY PICTURE!! NOW!!" he took the picture; and now gets along great with those guys!! So, it can be very beneficial to do things you would not normally do, or were not thinking of doing, in order to reach people. I sometimes have used carrots to witness to people, and sometimes; I have used 'Ol Betsy enclosed below to strike up a rapport with people, but there comes a time when we need to re-think where to draw a line in the sand. To me, Narnia should be one of those lines. banplease.gif

Posted

Quote:

Amelia said:

That would be easier to read if it were going counter clock wise.
tongue1.gif


Amelia! I am currently studying how to do this!!! peace.gif

Posted

Quote:

Who is Mike Ryan?


Sorry, I assumed certain familiarity with the SDA church and the basic facts.

Mike Ryan is the former head of Global Mission and now a general vice president of the General Conference. As head of global mission, it was his business to know what was reaching whom.

Quote:

What issues have we spent time arguing about that are such a snare to most in the Church?


Take a look at most of the threads here at CA. Is the man in Romans 7 converted? Was Christ pre-lapsarian or post-lapsarian? Should we eat cheese? Is the KJV the only true Bible? Should musical tempo be faster than a normal human heartbeat? The list is nearly endless.

Your posts indicate you're not really familiar with the area. That's O.K. I just don't have the time to do your homework. Don't get all offended, but it's a simple truth that if you didn't know who Mike Ryan was, you aren't conversant with the basics in this area.

Peruse George Barna's work. Learn about the Engel scale(again, these are basics). Consider the ratio of SDA's to population in NA (hint: we're shrinking)

According to William Johnsson (Editor of the Review) the average age of SDA's worldwide is 19. What's the average age in most churches in NA? Somewhere around 55.

Read "Present Truth in the Real World" (your ABC has it). Read Dead Languages and some of the 5 or so online pages denouncing it. At least become familiar with some of the debate.

Attend a Seeds conference or two (I've been to eight).

Oh, yes, and read some C.S. Lewis. Read the Chronicles of Narnia, but not until you've read Mere Christianity, and Surprised by Joy.

That SDA's in NA are shrinking in proportion to the general population, and that we are rapidly aging should be obvious to anyone with eyes to see.

More than 50% of the Baby Boom generation left the church. Generation X (do you know that term? who they are?) are either not there to begin with, or leaving in similar numbers. The oldest X-ers are nearing 40. If we don't act soon, we'll lose another entire generation.

If you deny these numbers, you're just not paying attention.

“the slovenliness of our language makes it easier to have foolish thoughts.” George Orwell

Posted

Ed

The one answer I was hoping you would reply to was not addressed at all in your post above. I am not so sure I have categorically "denied" whatever numbers you are claiming re how many are being reached; and I am well aware that numbers are shrinking in NA. My specific intentions here have been to question the claims re Narnia...how many people is it really "reaching?" And just how is this "reaching" being done with Narnia?

You are right; there's a few things I don't know. But I can still question, as do many others, the true indications/validity of such "studies" because of how they are done. It really doesn't matter anyways about these numbers per se; as my questions have really been regarding the real usefulness of Narnia materials in "reaching" people, or *introducing* people to Jesus. I feel you have done a good job with what you did say so far; but is there a reason you do not answer this question specifically? I understand you are really busy; so don't worry re answering right away. Just something to think about.

LOL...What's really important to me now is that someone needs to tell me what on earth "pre-lapsarian," and "post-lapsarian" is!! I actually don't like to get too involved with such issues anymore. It doesn't pay good enough. But I honestly have no idea what these two things are!! And the curiosity is really intense. It sounds like a new kind of salad or something. I think I'll go eat my "cheese" sandwich while I am waiting for your answer. (no. you can't ask what kind of cheese!!). smile.gifxmas44.gif

Posted

Quote:

"pre-lapsarian," and "post-lapsarian"


Did Christ take on the nature of Adam before the fall (pre-lapse) or after the fall (post-lapse). Other than to identify it, I don't want to talk about it.

Narnia discussion takes longer, and I'm finishing up dialogue (our church plant's mode of sermon) for today's service.

“the slovenliness of our language makes it easier to have foolish thoughts.” George Orwell

Posted

Oh boy THAT can of worms ... can't say I blame Ed for not wanting to discuss it but I can't resist offering my position on it: since it would have been meaningless otherwise, not to mention impossible to accomplish using human DNA, he clearly took the nature of Adam AFTER the fall. That is, if we are talking about the biological specifics of his incarnation. If we are referring to something ELSE as "his nature" -- if we are using "nature" to mean CHARACTER or something NON-PHYSICAL, then it's up for grabs and more likely to correspond with that of Adam BEFORE the fall, i.e., knowing no sin.

But the entire argument hinges on what we define as "his nature" -- and that's the bit people fail to comprehend when arguing it. They are trying to argue apples and oranges half the time, and come to blows over it.

"After such knowledge, what forgiveness?" -- T.S. Eliot
Posted

Quote:

Ed Dickerson said:

Quote:

"pre-lapsarian," and "post-lapsarian"


Did Christ take on the nature of Adam before the fall (pre-lapse) or after the fall (post-lapse). Other than to identify it, I don't want to talk about it.

Narnia discussion takes longer, and I'm finishing up dialogue (our church plant's mode of sermon) for today's service.


LOL...We are in agreement there ED. thankyousign.gif
  • 2 months later...
Posted

Hello Ed

I thought you were going to continue a bit with discussing Narnia here? I know you are likely busy but when you get a chance I would like to hear more.

Posted

Meanwhile I'm scratching my head over my posts just two months ago wondering what planet was I on???

Here's a VERY excellent discussion of Narnia. If you aren't a Salon.com subscriber, get the day pass if you need it to see the content -- it's well worth it, and requires NO personal info, just a quick click-through of two buttons.

http://www.salon.com/ent/movies/feature/2005/12/07/narnia/

The article objectively discusses things you've raised, David -- about decidedly non-Christian elements in the story, etc. -- and ultimately gets to the heart of what really attracts people to Narnia and its genre cousins.

Enjoy!

~Nico

"After such knowledge, what forgiveness?" -- T.S. Eliot
Posted

Hey Thanks Nico! smile.gif

Your posts don't look half as bad as some of mine from the past...:) Anyways, this is the kind of info I am interested in looking at. I will check it out.

Posted

Quote:

Ed Dickerson said:

all Christians are in the business of Myth


[:"red"] "For we have not followed cunningly devised fables, when we made known unto you the power and coming of our Lord Jesus Christ..." [/] 2 Peter 1:16 KJV

DOVE.gif

Lift Jesus up!!

Posted

You know, Nico, I read this article and thought it was interesting--I have read TONS about this movie/the books. I have thought about it TONS. Without "recommending" that someone saw the movie, can it not still be used as a starting point? For example, the movie has recently come to HK (we always get them a couple months late because of dubbing and subtitles). Many of my students have seen it without knowing anything more about it than that it's a fantasy movie. They love it as that, but see no more in it than that. If I were to engage them in dialogue about the movie, the books, and some of the Christian meanings behind it, would it help or hinder them? I teach at a Christian school but most of my students are not Christian. As with many arguments and discussions, I feel myself in the middle on this one; on the one side, I do not want to introduce someone, however unwittingly, to something that may lead them farther away from Christianity. Would/Could Narnia do that? Apparently, according to some I've read. On the other hand, I remember reading the books for the first time in grade 10 and seeing Christ all the way through them. I was naively unaware of other issues at the time, and it never even crossed my mind that these were anything but Christian. In the meantime, I've recommended them to students and friends. Now, I start reading the 'historians' and deconstructionists (which, though I am a literature teacher, I have never totally been comfortable with) and wondering, Wow, have I been wrong all these years? Was my experience with these books wrong/false?

I really don't know what to think about this topic anymore.

M

Posted

Michelle, maybe it is helpful to picture everyone in the world at any given time occupying space/time in a four-dimensional grid. At any given point of occupation are things I call flagstones or touchstones. These are like "dots" which can be connected by the Holy Spirit to lead someone to Christ. Some of these dots represent a step backwards or off the forward-going vector toward Christ for some people, depending on the spot they currently occupy. Others represent the next "link in the chain" as it were for other folks, depending on what spot they currently occupy.

There's a lot of principles we could extract from Scripture along this point ... "we can do nothing against the truth, but for the truth ..." AND YET "all things are lawful unto me, but not all things are expedient ..." We have "it is not that which goes into a man which defiles but that which comes out ..." AND YET "to him that knoweth to do good, and doeth it not, to him it is sin." Or if you prefer (speaking facetiously here, but with a point) I could refer to a spontaneous transmission I received once, from a source identified only as "Channel 23", telling me that "nothing in the universe is ever wasted." Was that statement truth? A better question might be: Shall we judge such a question upon the source or upon the content -- or upon the use to which that content is put? Because -- careful, now! -- each criteria renders a potentially different answer.

What am I trying to say? I'm trying to say a lot of things at once. Chief among them: our God is in control of everything, ultimately, even Satan. Psalm 139 makes it clear that we could go to the utter pit of hell, even make our bed there and sleep with the devil, and still we cannot flee from His Spirit. If He wills to make His presence and His love known in the darkest of places, He will do so -- and having seen what I've seen of the enemy's kingdom, I'd hardly class a child's fantasy story featuring an analogy of the death and resurrection of the Lord -- witches and satyrs notwithstanding -- one of existence's darkest corners.

But I think it's important to recognize that in most cases, people -- particularly those who don't ALREADY have the Christ story to "plug in" to it -- aren't interested in Narnia because it teaches them about Jesus' love. (And as an aside ... that's OUR job ... by LIVING it, that is, not ONLY telling the tale ...) They are interested in immersion in the entire realm which is conjured in order to tell the story. They are interested in that immersion because something obviously appeals about that world which they do not believe they can find in their experience of the "real" world. And ultimately, whether we use Narnia as a springboard or not, we have far better news for them: namely, that they don't have to escape to a fantasy world to experience the best "deep magic" in the universe. It's right here, in our very real world, accessible by faith, demonstrated in the incarnation, life and death of Christ.

Blessings,

Nico

"After such knowledge, what forgiveness?" -- T.S. Eliot
Posted

It was a sunday afternoon. The latest, greatest, most wonderful movie had just been released in theaters and the father's two children wanted to see it.

"Please Dad! Please! It's a great movie, no swearing, and only a little bit of fantasy... It tells a great story! There's hardly anything wrong with it at all!"

Dad said no.

"But Dad! Please! Everyone is going! It's going to be awesome, and my teacher assigned us homework on it!"

To which Dad replied, "Are you going to do everythingeveryone else does?"

"Well no, of course not, Dad!" Still the answer was no.

A little while later, the children smelled the wonderful odor of baking brownies.... MMMMmmmmmm they thought. Mom's making brownies because Dad won't let us go to the movies! And away they raced to the kitchen.

Cooling on the kitchen counter was a pan full of brownies, but it was DADsitting at the kitchen table reading the Sunday paper.

"Can we have some brownies?" asked the kids. "Sure kids, but first I need to tell you something." replied Dad.

"I made these brownies for you. They are delicious, with the very best ingredients. When I finished mixing up the batter, I went outside, and I got 1 teaspoon of Rex's poo, and mixed it up in the batter.

You may have some if you want. It will taste good, it will be wonderful, I'm sure. It's only a little, teeny, tiny bit out of the wonderful treat that's not good for you. It's up to you. It's just a little bit bad...."

~Author Unknown~

A heart where He alone has first place.

Posted

Yes, that is one way of looking at it. There are others.

It's a big universe and an even bigger God. That's why I listed all those (seemingly) conflicting principles above. Remember we also have the apostle Paul's example of reasoning beginning with where the people were "at" on Mars Hill (temple of the Unknown God) and using that as a launching point to talk about the real God -- as well as his testimony that he became "all things to all men" that he might "by any means save some."

A lot to look at here, indeed.

I think better than the poo-brownies analogy is the analogy of the knife or scalpel. In the hands of someone with malicious intent it becomes a tool for that malice. Yet in the hands of a skilled surgeon, it becomes an instrument of saving lives.

Of course in the hand of the greedy merchandiser it can just become the mechanism for slicing up bits of garnish which he then sells at inflated prices to those for whom simple food is deemed unpalatable on its own ...

In any case, I do think we would rightly be accused of practicing bad medicine if we insisted ALL cases of illness or injury required the knife and failure to render them such meant we were in danger of forcing nearby hunks of granite and gneiss to shriek in protest that we "aren't doing anything." shocked.gif

There are the rocks, and there are the pebbles ... the former may indeed cry out if none else will testify, but the latter just tend to become a nuisance in the shoe. grin.gif

"After such knowledge, what forgiveness?" -- T.S. Eliot
Posted

Well; I don't know...seems to me Rex would not be a candidate for ciphering morals...

Quote:

by Nico:
I think better than the poo-brownies analogy is the analogy of the knife or scalpel. In the hands of someone with malicious intent it becomes a tool for that malice. Yet in the hands of a skilled surgeon, it becomes an instrument of saving lives.


As much as I would not personally use something like Narnia; I can find agreement with this line of thought. Atleast there is some possibility there.

Posted

Well, calgary_guy,

I don't have a lot of time to invest.

Meanwhile, I'm continually involved in these issues. Just completed several assignments for SDA publications. I have several projects going on. One to reach the 96-97% we're currently ignoring, and another to help those who care understand how to reach the larger audience and why we must.

I'm involved in a church plant that has a median age of 26. If we didn't have this church plant, the young couples who attend would have no church that they would find welcoming.

By your own testimony, you don't know the issues or the players, and seem disiclined to find out.

So it's just a matter of priorities.

“the slovenliness of our language makes it easier to have foolish thoughts.” George Orwell

Posted

Thanks Nico. I appreciate your analogies and answer. I'm still really thinking about many things in relation to Narnia . . . .

M

Posted

LHC, you often post irrelevant scriptural references, but this one takes the cake.

If you don't know the difference between Myth, fable, parable, and allegory, you might inquire before applying a convenient "proof-text."

Misuse of Scripture in that way is one of the primary reasons that contemporary people no longer believe in the Bible. They've seen it so badly misused so often they just don't care any more.

Christians are in the business of Myth, because we're in the business of explaining a reality that includes the supernatural.

Myth is not fable. Myth is a symbolic explanation of the reality which goes beyond nature to the supernatural. It's symbolic because much of that reality is beyond or outside of our experience. Since we cannot have specific terms for things outside of our experience, we use figurative or symbolic language.

That's why so much of the Bible is in figurative and symbolic language.

Please, please, stop throwing verses around without seeking to understand what the poster is saying.

“the slovenliness of our language makes it easier to have foolish thoughts.” George Orwell

Posted

poo is often in the eye of the beholder.

“the slovenliness of our language makes it easier to have foolish thoughts.” George Orwell

Posted

Quote:

Ed Dickerson said:

Well, calgary_guy,

I don't have a lot of time to invest.

Meanwhile, I'm continually involved in these issues. Just completed several assignments for SDA publications. I have several projects going on. One to reach the 96-97% we're currently ignoring, and another to help those who care understand how to reach the larger audience and why we must.

[:"red"]This sounds quite impressive Ed; but I have tried a number of times here to get you to tell us something really specific that you are doing with whom, and what are the real results. How many of this 96% are you really reaching with Narnia - and what are you classing as "reaching?"

I'm involved in a church plant that has a median age of 26. If we didn't have this church plant, the young couples who attend would have no church that they would find welcoming.

By your own testimony, you don't know the issues or the players, and seem disiclined to find out.

So it's just a matter of priorities.


[:"red"]Your constant attempts at personalizing this issue to the point where you know my motives, and intentions are questionable. As you say it; I don't care about "reaching" the 96%, so I guess that settles it, eh?

I have a little something that I have been relating to Church members who do care about reaching out to those we currently do not pay much attention to; but I still don't get why I need Narnia to do it. My original point here was that some call narnia "Christian;" just because CS Lewis wrote it; but I have been studying his works for a while now; and much of it is not Christian at all.

If you want to use a "good" story with a "good" moral to it to "reach" someone for Jesus, then fine. I agree that sometimes can be done; but I cannot accept that Narnia is "Christian."

I would sure be interested to see some actual results of your Narnia Thumping. I wonder how many of your "Church Plant" wil still be there in 2 years? Time will tell us all about that I guess.

Quote:

Standing In The Way Of Those Standing In Need?

It seems to me that the Lord is giving the erring, the weak and trembling, and even those who have apostatized from the truth, a special call to come fully into the fold. But there are but few in our churches who feel that this is the case.

And there are still fewer who stand where they can help such.

There are more who stand directly in the way of these poor souls. Very many have an exacting spirit. They require them to come to just such and such terms before they will reach to them the helping hand. Thus they hold them off at arms' length. They have not learned that they have a special duty to go and search for these lost sheep.

They must not wait till these come to them.

Read the touching parable of the lost sheep. Luke 15:1-7:

"Then drew near unto Him all the publicans and sinners for to hear Him. And the Pharisees and scribes murmured, saying, This Man receiveth sinners, and eateth with them. And He spake this parable unto them, saying, What man of you, having an hundred sheep, if he lose one of them, doth not leave the ninety and nine in the wilderness, and go after that which is lost, until he find it?

And when he hath found it, he layeth it on his shoulders, rejoicing. And when he cometh home, he calleth together his friends and neighbors, saying unto them, Rejoice with me; for I have found my sheep which was lost. I say unto you, that likewise joy shall be in heaven over one sinner that repenteth, more than over ninety and nine just persons, which need no repentance." by Ellen G White: 2T.020.002


Ed; FYI, I care much more about this issue than you will ever know. I am doing something about it personally too, according to the above model set forth in 2T, 20. It works really well, with all age and income brackets; and you don't need any fancy movies or evangelism sideshows to love people where they are at. That is the only way anything we do will work. Our "Programs" are all so sick. No wonder each of the many new ones constantly arising never "works."

Posted

Quote:

As you say it; I don't care about "reaching" the 96%, so I guess that settles it, eh?


Please reread previous post, and limit yourself to my actual words. I never said anything about you at all.

If you're going to supply both sides of the conversation, I'm not needed.

Like I said, priorities.

“the slovenliness of our language makes it easier to have foolish thoughts.” George Orwell

Posted

Quote:

Ed Dickerson said:

Well, calgary_guy,

By your own testimony, you don't know the issues or the players, and seem disiclined to find out.

So it's just a matter of priorities.


Ed; if you weren't talking about me here; then it must be my secret twin brother.

As I said; you seem to have your mind made up; and that you have the same attitude towards anyone who dares to disagree with Narnia Thumping. You keep saying "I am not needed" and avoiding answering my questions here.

What are the specific results of your Narnia Evangelism; how much of the 96% are you really "reaching;" and what do you class as "reaching" them? If you know Church stats so well; surely you'd also know that this type of "Evangelism" has never been shown to retain memberships in the Church.

Do they use Narnia in the areas of the world where the Church is most growing? No. They use the Bible.

Join the conversation

You can post now and register later. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.

Guest
Reply to this topic...

×   Pasted as rich text.   Paste as plain text instead

  Only 75 emoji are allowed.

×   Your link has been automatically embedded.   Display as a link instead

×   Your previous content has been restored.   Clear editor

×   You cannot paste images directly. Upload or insert images from URL.


If you find some value to this community, please help out with a few dollars per month.



×
×
  • Create New...